top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

Product Liability for Contractors and Developers – The Defective Products Liability Law and the Torts Ordinance

Jan 10, 2020

Product Liability for Contractors and Developers – The Defective Products Liability Law and the Torts Ordinance

Contractor/Developer Liability Under the Defective Products Law

The Defective Products Law, 1980 (hereinafter: the “Defective Products Law” or the “Law”) establishes strict liability for the manufacturer (in our context: the contractor/developer) for bodily injury caused by a defect or flaw in a building. Note that Section 1 of the Law defines a “product” as:

“A product attached to real estate, including a building.”

Think this is far-fetched? Or the kind of trouble you can deal with if it arises? Not at all.

The Law provides significant tools for the injured party. First, Section 2 of the Defective Products Law stipulates that liability does not depend on negligence, act, or omission. In other words:

“A manufacturer must compensate anyone who suffers bodily injury due to a defect in a product they manufactured, regardless of whether the manufacturer was at fault.”

Additionally, the Law establishes a presumption of liability for the contractor/developer if the circumstances of the case are more consistent with the conclusion that the product was defective than with the conclusion that it was sound.

Moreover, since a building is considered a “product,” the various elements that compose it or are installed in it are also considered components of the product. This includes building design and the work performed to construct it. Accordingly, in the chain of liability under the Law, alongside the contractor, the component manufacturer and the building designer may also be liable, depending on the circumstances, and their responsibility for bodily injuries caused by one of the components will be examined.

For example, consider a scenario where a tile falls on a child playing in the building’s yard two years after the building was handed over to residents, and it is found that neither the homeowners’ association nor the residents made any changes to the exterior cladding. This would indicate a defect in the external cladding.

​

Product Liability for Contractors and Developers – The Defective Products Liability Law and the Torts Ordinance

Liability of the contractor/developer based on the Torts Ordinance

Alongside the Defective Products Liability Law, under which the injured party does not need to prove negligence on the part of the contractor/developer, the injured party has the option of filing a claim under the Torts Ordinance (New Version), 1968, by virtue of the tort of negligence under sections 35-36 of the Ordinance. In the event of such a claim, the injured party must prove the defendant's negligence.

​

If, in the case of personal injury, the cause of action can be based on both laws, in all matters concerning property damage or financial damage caused as a result of a defect or defect in construction - the liability of the contractor or developer will apply according to the Torts Ordinance.

​

Product liability insurance provides a solution to both of these paths: both bodily injury claims under the Defective Products Liability Law and claims based on the Torts Ordinance for bodily injury or property damage.

The contractor/developer's exposure period to claims

The contractor/developer's exposure period to claims

While contractor's work insurance or professional liability insurance is usually intended for the period of time that the project is in progress, product liability insurance provides long-term protection after the project is completed.

 The exposure period for a claim under the Defective Products Liability Law is 10 years, while the exposure period under the Torts Ordinance is much longer and is also related to the Sales Law (Apartments). As is known, according to the Sales Law, the warranty period lasts up to 10 years depending on the component in question according to a warranty table specified in the law, but in certain cases - such as a warranty for construction - it lasts even 20 years. 


 A claim under the Torts Ordinance is based on the above warranty periods, although they do not constitute rivets.
We have already encountered a claim for bodily and property damage resulting from an electrical short circuit that caused a fire in the building 9 years after it was delivered for use. 


 The fire quickly spread from the main panel on the ground floor to all floors of the building. The fire investigator appointed by the insurance company that insured the building for the House Committee found that the fire separations were carried out negligently and hence the path to filing a claim under the Torts Ordinance was short. Although the warranty period had expired, the insurance company that compensated the tenants filed a subrogation claim against the developer, relying on the tort of negligence under sections 35-36 of the Torts Ordinance.


While Contractors’ All Risks insurance and professional indemnity insurance are generally intended for the period during which a project is under construction, product liability insurance provides long term protection after its completion.

The period of exposure to claims under the Defective Products Liability Law is 10 years, whereas exposure under the Torts Ordinance extends considerably longer and is also linked to the Sale (Apartments) Law. Under the Sale (Apartments) Law, the liability period lasts up to 10 years, depending on the component concerned and the schedule specified in the Law. In certain cases, such as liability for the structural framework, it can extend to 20 years.

Claims under the Torts Ordinance draw on these liability periods, although they are not definitive limits. We have encountered a claim for bodily injury and property damage arising from an electrical short circuit that caused a fire in a building nine years after it was handed over for use.

The fire spread rapidly from the main electrical distribution board on the ground floor to every floor of the building. A fire investigator appointed by the insurer that covered the building on behalf of the residents’ committee found that the fire compartmentation had been negligently installed. A claim under the Torts Ordinance soon followed.

Although the liability period had expired, the insurer that compensated the residents brought a subrogation claim against the developer, relying on the tort of negligence under Sections 35 and 36 of the Torts Ordinance.

​

The protections that the law provides to the manufacturer - the developer/contractor

The Defective Products Law lists a number of defenses that the contractor/developer can avail themselves of on the day of the order and depending on the circumstances. Below are some of the most important of them: 

  •  The defect in the structure was created after the structure left the contractor/developer's control: If the contractor proves that the structure passed all safety and standard tests before it left his control, it is presumed that the damage was caused by a defect that occurred subsequently. For example: A short circuit in a residential apartment that was split after it was built by the buyer caused a fire. It was determined that the buyer split the electrical panel amateurishly, resulting in the short circuit and fire. The developer was found to be exempt from liability. 
  •  Technological development - The contractor/developer could not have known that the design would not meet the reasonable level of safety according to the level of scientific and technological development that existed when the product was out of his control. For example, the building was built exactly according to the earthquake standard but collapsed during an earthquake and people were injured. 
  •  The structure went out of the contractor's/developer's control involuntarily - The structure went out of the developer's/contractor's control involuntarily and he took all reasonable measures to prevent it from going out of his control, including warning the public concerned about the risk involved in the structure. 
  •  The victim's awareness of the risk - the victim knew about the defect in the product and the risk involved and voluntarily exposed himself to this risk.

The protections that the law provides to the manufacturer - the developer/contractor

The Defective Products Liability Law provides several defences that contractors and developers may rely on when facing a claim, depending on the circumstances. Key examples include:

  • The defect arose after the building left the contractor’s or developer’s control: If the contractor proves that the building passed all safety and standards compliance checks before leaving their control, the damage is presumed to have resulted from a defect that arose subsequently. For example, an electrical short circuit caused a fire in an apartment that the purchaser had subdivided after construction. It emerged that the purchaser had improperly modified the electrical distribution board, causing the short circuit and fire. The developer was found not liable.

  • Scientific and technological developments: The contractor or developer could not have known that the design would fail to meet a reasonable safety standard, given the scientific and technological knowledge available when the product left their control. For example, a building was constructed in full compliance with the earthquake resistance standard but collapsed during an earthquake, causing bodily injuries.

  • The building left the contractor’s or developer’s control against their will: The building left their control involuntarily, despite their having taken all reasonable measures to prevent this, including warning the relevant public about the risks associated with the building.

  • The injured person’s awareness of the risk: The injured person knew about the product defect and the associated risk and voluntarily exposed themselves to that risk.

Is the donor at fault?

Is the donor at fault?

Israeli tort law states that the injured party can be held "contributory fault" if his behavior influenced the damage caused to him. According to the Defective Products Law, the injured party can be held "contributory fault" in cases of gross negligence on his part.

A special emphasis and importance in the law regarding children - if the injured party was under the age of 12, the defense regarding the injured party's knowledge of the product defect will not apply and the court will not reduce compensation by virtue of "contributory fault."

It should also be noted that product liability insurance does not cover claims originating in the relationship between the contractor/developer and the purchaser, regarding property damage and/or financial damages related to the quality of the construction. The contractor is exposed to claims under the Torts Ordinance and the Contracts Law regarding damages related to the quality of the construction, and issues related to the relationship between the parties in light of the Sales Law (Apartments), 5733-1973, the regulations thereunder and Amendment 3, 5791990.

Summary of information on liability for defects according to the Apartment Sales Law .

Israeli tort law allows contributory negligence to be attributed to an injured person if their conduct contributed to the harm they suffered. Under the Defective Products Liability Law, contributory negligence may be attributed to the injured person in cases of gross negligence on their part.

The Law includes a particularly important provision concerning children: if the injured person was under 12 years old, the defence based on their knowledge of the product defect does not apply, and the court will not reduce compensation on the grounds of contributory negligence.

It should also be noted that product liability insurance does not cover claims arising from the contractual relationship between the contractor or developer and the purchaser concerning property damage or financial losses related to construction quality. The contractor remains exposed to claims under the Torts Ordinance and contract law concerning construction quality, as well as issues arising from the relationship between the parties under the Sale (Apartments) Law, 1973, its associated regulations, and Amendment No. 3 of 1990.

Summary of liability for defects under the Sale (Apartments) Law.

Retroactive coverage when purchasing product liability insurance

One of the important issues regarding product liability insurance for contractors is retroactive coverage at any given time. Product liability insurance for contracting companies is a "Claims Made" policy, meaning that the insurance will only provide a solution if two cumulative conditions are met: the policy was valid both at the time of the damage or accident and at the time the claim was filed. Given that both cumulative conditions were met, the policy that will cover the claim is the policy in effect at the time the claim was filed. 


 Product liability insurance for contractors must be renewed every year and care must be taken to ensure continuity and retroactive coverage when switching between policies and/or from one insurance company to another. It is important to remember that claims that can be covered by product liability insurance for contractor companies may arise even many years after delivery. 


 It is recommended to read the article on the implications of not renewing professional liability and product liability policies . 


 Yes, we know. You've probably already said to yourself: "This is going to cost me a lot of money, especially since product liability insurance is ongoing insurance." Yes, but... this is exactly where we come into the picture.


Retroactive coverage when purchasing product liability insurance

What is the difference between product liability and maintenance coverage under contractor insurance?

Many contractors believe that they have protection even after delivery (full or partial) by virtue of the coverage for damage during maintenance work that is part of the contractor's insurance. Well, this is a mistake. Maintenance work coverage, as the name suggests. This is an insurance solution that provides coverage only for damage caused during maintenance work and not due to product defects. 


 It is important to know that the maintenance period is not an extension of the contractor's insurance policy. The coverage is also limited in time and is usually purchased for a period of 12 months or 24 months.

 Product liability insurance, unlike the definition of the maintenance period in the contractor's policy, is aimed at damages caused after delivery (partial or full) and for years to come. Long after the last worker leaves the construction site permanently.


What is the difference between product liability and maintenance coverage under contractor insurance?

​

​

​

​

​

Product Liability for Contractors and Developers – The Defective Products Liability Law and the Torts Ordinance

​

​

​

Product Liability for Contractors and Developers – The Defective Products Liability Law and the Torts Ordinance
Documents
Product Liability for Contractors and Developers – The Defective Products Liability Law and the Torts Ordinance
bottom of page