top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

Failure to update the list of works in the contractor work insurance negates compensation from the insurance company

Mar 27, 2018

Failure to update the list of works in the contractor work insurance negates compensation from the insurance company

Attorneys John Geva and Shlomi HadarGeva–Hadar Law Office, Attorneys at Law and Mediators


At the Tel Aviv Magistrates’ Court, the claim of A. v. ___ (the “Plaintiff”) was heard, represented by Adv. Arouah Younes, against Mr. ___ (the “Defendant”), represented by Adv. Ozer Berkowitz, and against a third party—Shomera Insurance Company Ltd. (the “Third Party” – “Shomera”), represented by Adv. Sharon Fogel. The judgment was rendered in February 2018, in the absence of the parties, by the Honorable Senior Judge Yael Henig.


Facts of the case:The plaintiff filed a claim for compensation for bodily injury allegedly caused to him as a result of pushing a heavy scaffold during work. The plaintiff is a resident of the Palestinian Authority and a construction worker by profession. The defendant is a renovation contractor who owns a business for construction and renovation works. The third party—Shomera—is the insurance company that insured the defendant during the relevant period under a declaratory contractors’ works insurance policy. The parties disputed the following issues: the occurrence of a traumatic incident, the injury and its circumstances; employer liability and contributory negligence; the medical disability; its functional implications; the plaintiff’s income and the amount of damage; and the existence of insurance coverage.


Parties’ arguments:According to the plaintiff, the defendant breached statutory duties owed to him pursuant to section 172 of the Safety at Work Ordinance [New Version], 1970. In addition, the defendant breached duties of care by failing to provide him with mechanical aids or assistance from another worker capable of participating in the pushing. There is a causal link between these breaches and the damage suffered. The plaintiff argued that no contributory negligence should be attributed to him, as he acted in accordance with the defendant’s instructions, did not take any unusual action, and was compelled to perform the pushing operation by himself.


According to the defendant, there are no statutory duties under the law regarding excessive weight. In the absence of a statutory duty and in the absence of an expert safety opinion, the plaintiff failed to prove that the defendant was required to take protective measures. The defendant further argued that no concrete duty of care should be imposed, as this was an unforeseeable risk under the circumstances. An incident in which the plaintiff’s back or neck “caught” resulted from the ordinary and natural risk inherent in this type of work—particularly in his case, as a veteran worker with prior experience working under similar field conditions.


Shomera argued that there was no insurance coverage because the defendant notified it of the work at the Dan Hotel more than two months after the accident and after having knowledge of the traumatic incident.

​

Failure to update the list of works in the contractor work insurance negates compensation from the insurance company

​

​

The Court held that the claimant had established, on the balance of probabilities, that the accident occurred in the circumstances he described. In considering liability, it noted that an employer’s duty of care toward an employee includes providing a safe working environment, safe tools and equipment, appropriate working methods, training, warnings about work-related risks, and supervision to ensure that the necessary precautions are taken (Supreme Court judgments in Shirazian v. Lavidai Ashkelon Ltd. and Boaron v. Netanya Municipality).

An employer will be liable if found negligent, meaning that the damage resulted from a departure from the standard of conduct expected of a reasonable employer in the circumstances. Such a departure may involve creating an unreasonable risk or failing to take reasonable measures to prevent a foreseeable, unreasonable risk from materializing.

The Court held that back injuries resulting from lifting loads are foreseeable and form part of the ordinary risks of life. An employer is not generally liable when an employee injures their back while lifting, except where lifting particularly heavy objects creates an unusual risk. In those circumstances, the employer must take reasonable precautions to prevent injury.

The starting point for assessing the defendant’s negligence was the scaffolding’s weight. No expert opinion was needed to establish that pushing a load three or four times heavier than the weight permitted under the Youth Employment Regulations exceeded the reasonable risks associated with a construction worker’s job and created an unreasonable risk.

The Court emphasized that the defendant had created this unreasonable risk and was therefore required to take reasonable precautions. The claimant readily satisfied the causation tests, establishing that complying with the defendant’s instructions under the conditions imposed had caused his injury. Legal causation was established under the prevailing risk test, as well as the foreseeability and common sense tests: the defendant could have foreseen the injury resulting from the risk he created without taking reasonable precautions.

The Court rejected the defendant’s allegation of contributory negligence, since he had created the risk and withheld the means of protection against it. The claimant had worked at the very centre of that risk and was injured while using his body, the only “means” the defendant had provided for performing the task. The defendant had therefore been negligent and was required to compensate the claimant.

The defendant had purchased a Contractors’ All Risks policy from Shomera that included employers’ liability coverage. The policy schedule listed declared works at two sites, but the Dan Hotel, where the work took place, was not among them.

This was a declaration-based policy under which coverage terms for multiple jobs were agreed in advance, with each job covered subject to the insured’s declaration. Coverage was conditional on notification before each job began.

Shomera argued that no coverage existed because the defendant had notified it of the work more than two months after the accident. This alone was sufficient to dismiss the third party claim. The Court noted that accepting the defendant’s position would mean recognizing an insurance contract covering a risk that had already passed, or an insured event that had already occurred when the contract was concluded. This would be inconsistent with Section 16(a) of the Insurance Contract Law, 1981.

In conclusion: The Court upheld the claimant’s claim and dismissed the third party claim. It ordered the defendant to pay the amount claimed, together with legal fees, the fees of the claimant’s medical expert, and the court filing fee. The defendant was also ordered to pay Shomera’s legal fees and the court filing fee relating to the third party proceedings.

As of the time of writing, it is not known whether an appeal has been filed with the District Court.

The verdict

The court ruled that the plaintiff was able to tip the balance of probabilities in his favor and prove the accident and its circumstances. The court discussed liability for the accident and noted that , within the framework of an employer's duty of care towards an employee, he must ensure a safe work environment, provide the employee with safety tools and devices, ensure proper work methods, instruct the employee, warn him of the risks involved in performing his work, and supervise the taking of necessary precautions (Supreme Court rulings Shirazian v. Levyd Ashkelon Ltd., Bo'aron v. Netanya Municipality). The employer will be liable if it is found that he was negligent, that is, that the damage was caused as a result of his deviation from the norm of behavior of a reasonable employer, under the circumstances of the case. Deviation can be expressed in creating an unreasonable risk or in failing to take reasonable measures to prevent the materialization of an unreasonable risk, provided that it is a foreseeable risk.

The court ruled that back injury resulting from lifting loads is an expected risk and part of the risks of life. An employer will not be held liable for the damage of an employee whose back is injured due to lifting loads, except in those cases where an unusual risk is created as a result of lifting particularly heavy objects. In these cases, the employer must take reasonable measures to prevent the danger from materializing. The starting point for examining the defendant's negligence is the weight of the scaffold. There is no need for an expert opinion to determine that pushing a weight that is three or four times higher than the weight permitted under the Youth Labor Regulations exceeds the reasonable risks at a construction worker's workplace and creates an unreasonable risk.

The court emphasized that this goes beyond the reasonable risks at the workplace of a construction worker, creating an unreasonable risk that the defendant created, and which required him to take reasonable measures. The plaintiff easily passed the tests of causal connection and proved that his compliance with the defendant's demand, under the conditions he dictated, caused the damage. The legal connection exists both according to the test of the prevailing risk, and according to the tests of anticipation and common sense, according to which the defendant could have anticipated the damage that would be caused to the plaintiff in light of the risk he created, without taking reasonable measures.
The court ruled that the defendant cannot be heard on the claim of contributory fault since he created the risk and prevented the means to protect himself from it. The plaintiff acted at the heart of this risk and was injured while using his body, the only "means" that the defendant made available to him for the purpose of performing the work. The defendant was negligent and must compensate the plaintiff for his damages.

The defendant purchased a contractor work insurance policy from Shomra that covers, among other things, employer liability. The list in the policy specified declared work at two sites, and the Dan Hotel , where the work was performed , is not among them . This is a "declaratory" policy, in which the terms of insurance coverage for more than one job are summarized in advance, and the coverage for each job is according to the insured's declaration. The coverage here was conditioned on reporting before the start of each job . Shomra claimed that there was no insurance coverage because the defendant only notified her of the job more than two months after the accident, and this was sufficient to reject the notification to a third party. The court noted that accepting the defendant's position means recognizing an insurance contract to cover a risk that had already passed at the time the contract was concluded or an insured event that had already occurred at that time, and such recognition is inconsistent with Section 16(a) of the Insurance Contract Law, 5741-1981.

In summary: The court accepted the claim and rejected the third-party notice, ordering the defendant to pay the plaintiff the amount of the claim, plus attorney's fees, fees for a medical expert on his behalf, and legal fees. In addition, the defendant must pay the custodian attorney's fees and legal fees for the third-party notice.
** As of the date of this writing, it is unknown whether an appeal has been filed with the District Court.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Failure to update the list of works in the contractor work insurance negates compensation from the insurance company

​

​

​

Failure to update the list of works in the contractor work insurance negates compensation from the insurance company
Documents
Back
Failure to update the list of works in the contractor work insurance negates compensation from the insurance company
bottom of page