top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

Question about vehicle insurance requirements

Jul 29, 2018

Question about vehicle insurance requirements

Recently, I received a question from an insurance advisor for the client commissioning the finishing works on a floor in an office tower. The client arranges the contractor’s all-risk insurance themselves and is requiring our client—the main contractor—to obtain supplementary insurance: professional liability, product liability, and insurance for heavy construction machinery (HCM). It should be noted that our client, the main contractor, does not own any HCM, and if such equipment is required at all, it is brought on-site by subcontractors.


Here is the question:

We saw that the policy was expanded for the client’s project to include a negotiated limit for professional liability coverage, which is fine.However, as you can see, the insurer deleted coverage for property and HCM.

Although, according to the contract wording, the contractor may choose not to insure their own property (since there is an exemption clause), regarding HCM insurance, there is a component for third-party liability, including expanded indemnification toward the client. The deletion of this coverage is therefore problematic.


I would appreciate it if you could review this issue with the contractor.

​

Question about vehicle insurance requirements

​

​

  1. This is, of course, completely incorrect.

  2. A distinction must be drawn between construction plant and machinery that qualifies as a motor vehicle requiring compulsory motor insurance, and machinery that does not require such insurance.

  3. If the machinery qualifies as a motor vehicle requiring compulsory motor insurance, bodily injury is governed by the Compensation for Road Accident Victims Law, including its provisions on exclusivity of causes of action. For third party property damage, the Contractors’ All Risks policy for which you are responsible must include an extension covering liability above the offending vehicle’s liability limit. Had the Contractors’ All Risks insurance been arranged through us, this extension would have provided NIS 4 million in coverage.

  4. For construction plant and machinery that does not require compulsory motor insurance, you must ensure that the Contractors’ All Risks policy arranged by the party commissioning the work includes an extension covering bodily injury arising from its use, up to the full liability limit. Property damage should be covered in full under that policy, as its third party liability section should contain no exclusion for such damage. Had the insurance been arranged through us, no such exclusion would apply.

  5. In any event, the contractor owns no construction plant or machinery in this case and therefore holds no plant and machinery insurance.

  6. If construction plant or machinery is used on the project at all, the solution lies in the Contractors’ All Risks policy arranged by the party commissioning the work, together with a requirement for the contractor to ensure that any machinery brought onto the project by subcontractors that qualifies as a motor vehicle requiring compulsory motor insurance carries both compulsory motor insurance and third party liability insurance. In my view, such machinery is not being used here, since the project involves finishing work on upper floors.

To summarize:

  1. Most of the responsibility rests with the party commissioning the work, who arranged the Contractors’ All Risks insurance, to ensure that the policy is professionally and properly structured and includes the appropriate extensions described in paragraphs 3 to 5 above.

  2. The contractor must ensure that construction plant and machinery qualifying as motor vehicles carries compulsory motor insurance and third party liability insurance.

  3. It is customary to include a waiver of liability in favor of the party commissioning the work regarding subparagraph (b) above, as there is no practical way to administer this requirement. Including it in the supplementary certificate of insurance is a formality only.

Below is the answer I gave:

1. Of course this is a complete mistake.

2. A distinction must be made between a CMA vehicle, which is also a vehicle subject to mandatory insurance, and a CMA vehicle that is not subject to mandatory insurance.

3. If this is a vehicle that is subject to compulsory insurance - then in terms of bodily injury - it is subject to the Compensation for Road Accident Victims Law (including consolidation of causes), while in terms of third party property - you must purchase in the contractor policy under your responsibility an extension of coverage for third party property damage above the liability limit of the offending vehicle. (If we had contractor work insurance - then the coverage would be NIS 4 million for this section).

4. Regarding CMA tools that are not subject to mandatory insurance - it must be ensured that there is an extension in the contractor's policy that the client has taken out, for bodily injury resulting from the use of CMA tools within the full limit of liability, while in terms of property damage - the coverage should apply in full in the contractor's policy since there should be no exception to this in the third-party insurance in the contractor's policy. (If the works insurance were arranged through us - then there is no exception to this).

5. Either way - in this case, the contractor does not own any CMA equipment and therefore does not hold Clal CMA insurance.
6. If at all, CMA vehicles were used in the project (in my opinion, such vehicles were not used because this involves finishing work on high floors) - then the solution is in the contractor's policy that the client issues and in requiring the contractor to ensure that CMA vehicles, which are considered vehicles and require mandatory insurance - brought in by subcontractors, will be insured with mandatory and third-party insurance.

In conclusion:
1. It turns out that most of the burden here falls on the client who arranged the works insurance - to ensure that the policy is prepared properly and professionally and includes appropriate extensions as stated in sections 3-5.
2. The contractor, for his part, must ensure that mandatory and third-party insurance is in place for the CMA vehicles that are considered vehicles.
3. It is acceptable to include an exemption for the client in relation to what is stated in subsection B above because there is no practical way to manage this. Including the requirement in the confirmation of the existence of supplementary insurance is for the record only.



​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Question about vehicle insurance requirements

​

​

​

Question about vehicle insurance requirements
Documents
Back
Question about vehicle insurance requirements
bottom of page