top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

A worker who fell from scaffolding - who has to prove negligence?

Jul 10, 2018

A worker who fell from scaffolding - who has to prove negligence?

By: Attorneys John Geva and Shlomi HadarGeva-Hadar Law Office – Attorneys and Mediators


The Supreme Court heard an appeal against the decision of the Haifa District Court, which had itself acted as the appellate instance reviewing the decision of the Magistrate’s Court. The Supreme Court ruling was delivered on May 21, 2018, by a panel headed by Justice Y. Amit.


Background: On July 4, 2007, Mr. Gazi Narani, of blessed memory (hereinafter: “the deceased”), tragically died after falling from a significant height while working as a laborer on a construction site. The appellants in the case were the deceased’s estate and heirs, who stepped into his position and sued the contractor, subcontractor, and developer (hereinafter: “the contractors and developer”).


Throughout the proceedings, which took place across three judicial instances, the parties disputed the circumstances of the deceased’s fall. The appellants claimed that the deceased fell from an improperly installed scaffold at the site. In contrast, the contractors and developer argued that he fell from a seven-meter-high retaining wall located several meters away from the scaffold while walking on it to pour water into a nearby yard—a behavior indicating either the deceased’s responsibility for his own death or, at minimum, a contributory factor.

​

A worker who fell from scaffolding - who has to prove negligence?

​

​

The District Court held that, in the circumstances of the case, where it was unclear how the deceased had fallen to his death, responsibility for the accident rested with the contractors and the developer who had employed him. However, it also attributed 25% contributory negligence to the deceased. This finding was appealed.

The deceased’s heirs’ principal argument

The heirs’ principal argument relies on Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance, under which the burden of proof shifts from the claimant to the defendant in a claim for damages where three cumulative conditions are met:

  1. The claimant did not know, and could not have known, the actual circumstances that caused the incident resulting in the damage.

  2. The damage was caused by property over which the defendant had full control.

  3. The Court considers that the incident is more consistent with the defendant’s failure to exercise reasonable care than with the exercise of such care.

In simpler terms, where the claimant does not know how the damage occurred, the property involved was under the defendant’s control, and the Court considers negligence more likely than its absence, the burden shifts to the defendant to prove that they were not negligent. This reverses the usual rule that the party seeking compensation bears the burden of proving their claim.

District Court decision:

The District Court ruled that in the circumstances of the case, in which it is unclear how the deceased fell to his death, responsibility for the accident lies with the contractors and the developer (who employed the deceased), although it found it appropriate to impose contributory fault on the deceased at a rate of 25%, and the appeal was filed on this.

The main argument of the deceased's heirs:
The main argument of the deceased's heirs is based on section 41 of the Torts Ordinance, according to which the burden of proof will shift from the plaintiff to the defendant in a claim filed for damage when three cumulative items are met: (1) The plaintiff had no knowledge or was unable to know what the circumstances actually were that caused the event that resulted in the damage. (2) The damage was caused by property over which the defendant had full control. (3) It appears to the court that the event of the event that caused the damage is more consistent with the conclusion that the defendant did not exercise reasonable caution than with the conclusion that he exercised reasonable caution.
In simpler terms: when the plaintiff is unaware of the circumstances under which the damage occurred to property over which the defendant has control, and when the court believes that the event that caused the damage is more consistent with the conclusion that the defendant was negligent than that he was not negligent, the burden of proof that he was not negligent will shift to the defendant (and this is in contrast to the basic rule according to which "the one who produces the evidence bears the burden of proof" which generally places the burden of proof on the plaintiff).

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

A worker who fell from scaffolding - who has to prove negligence?

​

​

​

A worker who fell from scaffolding - who has to prove negligence?
Documents
Back
A worker who fell from scaffolding - who has to prove negligence?
bottom of page