top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

Who is responsible for the proper functioning of the cranes?

Mar 26, 2018

Who is responsible for the proper functioning of the cranes?

Article by: Adv. Eldan Danino, Shachar Mendelman Law Office, focusing on criminal law regarding fatal work accidents at construction sites.


“The responsibility for the proper functioning of cranes lies directly with the construction contractors and the engineers inspecting them, and not with the site managers.”


Introduction by: Itzick Simon

This is a quote from a landmark ruling by Judge Shaul Avinor of the Tel Aviv Magistrate’s Court, issued recently. Does this ruling have any implications for contractor insurance? Most likely: no. Does it have implications for the responsibility and insurance of the developer? That is worth considering. To some extent, it can be said that the days when a developer, general contractor, or site managers could completely absolve themselves of safety responsibility are over.


“The responsibility for the proper functioning of cranes lies directly with the construction contractors and the engineers inspecting them, and not with the site managers.”


This is the precedent-setting ruling of Judge Shaul Avinor, in which he determined that the overall responsibility for managing crane logbooks rests with the executing contractor itself, and that crane regulations do not impose on the site manager the duty to ensure that crane operators fulfill this responsibility.construction contractors and the engineers who inspect them, and not with

​

Who is responsible for the proper functioning of the cranes?

​

​

The Court issued this decision as part of its verdict concerning a serious workplace accident in October 2010. Crane operator Alexander Moiseychikov fell 50 metres to his death at a construction site operated by Malibu Construction Ltd. in Ramat Hasharon.

Following the accident, the Tel Aviv District Attorney’s Office (Criminal Division) filed charges of causing death by negligence against the site manager responsible for safety, alleging that he had failed to properly inspect the crane logbook recording its daily checks. Charges were also brought against crane operators who had worked on the same crane before the deceased.

Under the safety rules, tower cranes require specific professional expertise throughout their lifecycle, from erection at the site through operation, maintenance, and inspection to dismantling. This is particularly relevant today, when cranes at many construction sites are enormous structures reaching heights of tens of metres.

A tower crane’s operator cabin should have a metal grating on which the operator stands, with a reinforced glass window beneath it that allows the operator to observe the work area below.

In this case, the grating in the cabin that the deceased entered to work had been removed. The reinforced glass had also been replaced with a glued transparent Perspex panel. When he stepped on it, the panel came loose, causing him to fall 50 metres to his death.

Despite the gravity of the case and the loss of life, no indictment was filed against the construction contractor, Malibu Construction Ltd., and the company was not prosecuted. The Court strongly criticized the prosecution and police for failing to investigate the contractor while prosecuting lower ranking employees, even though the investigation conducted by the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs had identified additional safety deficiencies in the contractor’s conduct.

In its ruling, the Court expressly stated:

“…The specialist expertise required to deal with cranes is not, and cannot be, possessed by the site manager, who is generally not an engineer. It is therefore more reasonable and appropriate to impose crane supervision duties on the party carrying out the construction. Furthermore, construction sites where cranes are erected are large sites, and the parties carrying out the construction are consequently substantial commercial entities with the resources to engage suitable engineers and safety officers. There is therefore no logic or justification in exempting the party carrying out the construction from its statutory duties concerning the proper condition of cranes erected at the site, including supervision of the maintenance of the crane logbook.”

Ultimately, the Tel Aviv Magistrates’ Court acquitted the site manager and crane operator charged with causing death by negligence. It did so despite finding that the seriousness of the evidence and testimony presented to the Court indicated, on its face, substantial negligence by the party carrying out the construction in the sequence of events leading to the tragic accident.

The Court also directed the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs, as the responsible legislative authority, to address the legislative gap exposed by the case concerning the regulation of training and supervision for the erection of tower cranes at construction sites.

Criminal Case 10830-08-15, Tel Aviv–Yafo Magistrates’ Court, State of Israel v. Jabarin et al.

Counsel for the prosecution: State of Israel, Tel Aviv District Attorney’s Office (Criminal Division).Counsel for the defendants: Adv. Mohammed Jabarin and Adv. Nick Banari.

The author did not represent any party in this case.

Court decision

This decision of the court was given as part of the verdict regarding a serious work accident that occurred in October 2010, as a result of which a crane operator, the late Alexander Moiseychikov, fell to his death from a height of 50 meters at a construction site of the "Malibu Construction Ltd." company in Ramat Hasharon.

In connection with the accident, the Tel Aviv District Attorney's Office (Criminal) filed indictments for the offense of causing death by negligence against the foreman who was responsible for safety at the construction site in question, on the grounds that he did not properly check the crane logbook documenting the daily inspections performed on it, and also against the crane operators who worked on the same crane before the deceased.

From a professional perspective, according to safety rules, the care of a tower crane requires specific professional expertise, starting from the time it is erected on site, as well as during its operation, maintenance, and inspection, and ending with its dismantling, an issue that is becoming even more relevant these days, when on many job sites cranes are giant structures that rise to heights of dozens of meters.

In the operator's cabin of a tower crane, there should be a metal grid ("grating") installed on which the operator is supposed to work, and, underneath it, an armored glass window that allows the crane operator to observe the work area below him.

In this case, the grille in the cell to which the deceased had climbed to work was removed, and the armored window was replaced with a transparent plastic type - glued Plexiglas, which detached when the deceased stepped on it and as a result fell from a height of 50 meters to his death.

It should be noted that, although this was an extremely serious case that ended in the death of a person, no indictment was filed against the executing contractor, Malibu Construction Ltd., and the company was not prosecuted, a matter that was severely criticized by the court regarding the conduct of the Attorney General's Office and the police, for not finding it appropriate to investigate the executing contractor and prosecuted the junior employees, even though during the investigation conducted on behalf of the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, additional safety defects were found in the contractor's conduct.

As a matter of fact, in its ruling, the court explicitly states: "... that the special expertise required to handle cranes is not and cannot be possessed by the foreman, who is generally not an engineer. Therefore, it is more reasonable and more appropriate to impose the supervision duties regarding cranes on the construction operation . Furthermore, when it comes to construction sites where cranes are erected, these are large construction sites and in any case construction operations that are large economic entities that have the resources required to hire the services of the appropriate engineers and safety officers. Hence, there is also no logic or justification to exempt the construction operation from its obligations under the law in everything related to the proper maintenance of cranes erected at the construction site, including in the matter of supervision over the management of the crane register."

At the end of the day, because of this, the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court acquitted the construction manager and the contractor, who were prosecuted for causing death by negligence, despite its position that: "The seriousness of the evidence and the testimonies brought before the court indicate, ostensibly, actual negligence on the part of the construction operator in all matters concerning the chain of events that led to the tragic accident," while instructing the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, which is the legislator, to fill the legislative gap that was exposed in this case, in all matters related to regulating training and supervision of the erection of tower cranes at construction sites.

PO Box 10830-08-15 (Tel Aviv-Jaffa Magistrate's Court) State of Israel v. Jabarin et al.
Attorney for the prosecution: State of Israel – Tel Aviv District Attorney's Office (Criminal).
Attorneys for the defendants: Attorney Muhammad Jabarin and Attorney Nick Benri.
The writer did not represent anyone in this case.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Who is responsible for the proper functioning of the cranes?

​

​

​

Who is responsible for the proper functioning of the cranes?
Documents
Back
Who is responsible for the proper functioning of the cranes?
bottom of page