top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

Caution - the person commissioning the work can also be liable for a work accident (a worker falling from scaffolding)

Dec 30, 2018

Caution - the person commissioning the work can also be liable for a work accident (a worker falling from scaffolding)

By Attorneys John Geva and Shlomi Hadar


On September 25, 2018, an important ruling was issued by the Haifa District Court, addressing the liability of a contractor and the client for damages suffered by a worker who fell from scaffolding during his work. In addition to the contractor and the client, the worker sued Hachshara Insurance Company Ltd., which insured both defendants. The worker’s claim was joined by the National Insurance Institute (Bituach Leumi).


The facts were as follows: On March 15, 2015, the plaintiff was performing plastering work at the home of the client in Yokneam. At the end of the workday, the plaintiff attempted to descend from scaffolding installed at the site and fell approximately six meters to the ground, sustaining injuries.


The plaintiff filed a lawsuit against the client and the contracting company that employed him, claiming that they had negligently breached statutory obligations regarding worker safety on construction sites.


The defendants, on the other hand, argued that the plaintiff was an experienced and seasoned worker, who had also worked as a self-employed contractor employing others. They claimed that the plaintiff was responsible for his own injuries, as he had improvised a route to descend from the second floor and failed to use the designated and safe descent route on the other side of the building.

​

Caution - the person commissioning the work can also be liable for a work accident (a worker falling from scaffolding)

​

​

At the conclusion of the proceedings, the Court found that the construction company had been negligent toward the worker because the scaffolding had been erected negligently and a staircase used by workers to access their work had been left without a handrail. It could and should have been foreseen that workers would have difficulty ascending and descending the stairs and might veer toward the yard and fall.

The Court described the responsibility as “all the greater” where a person descending the stairs had to bend beneath low scaffolding, sit down, and slide down the steps. It added that no evidence had been presented showing that the claimant had another way to descend from the scaffolding.

The Court also held that the client could not absolve itself of responsibility merely by engaging a construction contractor. A reasonable client visiting the construction site could and should have ensured that safety requirements were observed and appropriate precautions taken to protect workers. As with the construction company, the client should have foreseen the accident and was negligent in failing to take measures to prevent the danger.

The Court attributed no contributory negligence to the worker. It ultimately held the construction company responsible for 75% of the damage and the client responsible for the remaining 25%.

It should be noted that just a few days ago, on 6 November 2018, the Histadrut reached an agreement requiring various government ministries to intervene and take measures to prevent construction site accidents, which have unfortunately become a nationwide scourge. Regarding scaffolding, the agreement stipulated that the Ministry of Labour would work to make the European standard mandatory for contractors at construction sites.

This may reduce accidents. However, as the case above illustrates, accidents can stem from negligence rather than noncompliance with standards. Since the consequences often include death or disability, clients, developers, and contractors undertaking construction work also face substantial risks. Addressing these generally requires supervision and enforcement of safety rules, alongside insurance covering the foreseeable risks.

Court decision

At the end of the proceedings, the court found that the contracting company was negligent towards the worker because the scaffolding was erected negligently and that allowing a staircase used by workers to ascend and descend for work purposes without a railing constituted negligence, as it was possible and should have been expected that workers would have difficulty ascending and descending it and that they might deviate towards the yard and fall.

According to the court, there is "double and multiple liability" in a situation where the person descending the stairs is forced to bend under a low scaffold, sit down and slide down the stairs. The court added that no evidence was presented that the plaintiff had any other way to get down from the scaffold.

The court also found that the client cannot exempt itself from liability by contracting with a construction contractor . According to the court, a "reasonable" client who visits the construction site should and could have ensured that safety instructions are being followed and that appropriate safety measures are being taken to ensure the safety of the workers on the site. Similar to the ruling against the contracting company, the client should have foreseen the accident and was negligent in not taking measures to prevent the danger.
The court refrained from imposing any contributory fault on the employee and ultimately determined that the contracting company was responsible for 75% of the damages, while the client was only responsible for 25%.

It should be noted here that just a few days ago, on November 6, 2018, the General Workers' Confederation reached an agreement that will oblige the various government ministries to intervene and take measures to prevent work accidents on construction sites that have unfortunately become a national scourge. This includes, in connection with scaffolding, the Ministry of Labor will work to make the European standard mandatory for contractors on construction sites. This may reduce accidents, but as the case described above shows, the source of accidents is not failure to comply with standards but negligence, and since the result usually ends in death or disability, it is also a significant risk that clients, contractors, and contractors take on when performing contract work, with the solution usually being supervision and implementation of safety rules alongside insurance that covers against the expected risks.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Caution - the person commissioning the work can also be liable for a work accident (a worker falling from scaffolding)

​

​

​

Caution - the person commissioning the work can also be liable for a work accident (a worker falling from scaffolding)
Documents
Back
Caution - the person commissioning the work can also be liable for a work accident (a worker falling from scaffolding)
bottom of page