top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

The Supreme Court takes another step, this time in interpreting a contractors' insurance policy.

Jul 23, 2017

The Supreme Court takes another step, this time in interpreting a contractors' insurance policy.

By: John Geva and Shlomi Hadar – Attorneys and Mediators


In June 2017, the Supreme Court issued a judgment (Honorable Justices H. Meltzer, C. Zilbertal, and N. Handel) in the appeal of Clal Insurance Company Ltd. (“Clal”) against B.Y.M. Construction Ltd. (“the Insured”), rejecting the insurer’s claim that the damages in question were excluded due to removal or weakening of ground support, while adopting interpretive rules favorable to the insured.


Case Facts:The insured is a construction company that won a tender from the Ministry of Construction and Housing to purchase and build 30 housing units. As part of this, it signed a program agreement with the Ministry and a development agreement with the Israel Land Authority. Clal was the insurance company that insured B.Y.M. under an All Risks Policy covering the project’s execution.


The proceedings between the parties arose from damages to six residential buildings caused by ground slippage at the construction site where the project was carried out (the “Event”).

The two main issues examined by the Supreme Court were:

  1. The allocation of responsibility for the Event between the insured and other parties, and

  2. The applicability and scope of Clal’s insurance policy.

​

The Supreme Court takes another step, this time in interpreting a contractors' insurance policy.

​

​

Regarding the allocation of liability, the District Court, whose judgment was appealed, held that the incident involved several tortfeasors who had caused a single, physically indivisible loss. However, it found that each tortfeasor’s contribution to the damage could be quantified conceptually. Accordingly, each was liable to pay compensation in proportion to their contribution to the damage.

The District Court further noted that, at the relevant time, the insured held a Contractors’ All Risks policy, including third party liability coverage. It rejected Clal Insurance’s argument that the damage was excluded under the standard policy because it had resulted from the removal or weakening of support to the ground further down the slope. The Court held that Clal’s interpretation was unreasonable and inconsistent with the policy’s purpose, as it would effectively render the policy meaningless, given that most construction work begins with excavation.

The appeal

The Supreme Court held that the breaches of the duties of care by the tortfeasors had caused a single loss. Each had participated in the events leading to the landslide, and their respective contributions could not be separated and individually attributed.

The Supreme Court emphasized that joint tortfeasors are jointly and severally liable. In particular, where one tortfeasor is insolvent, the resulting financial burden falls on another tortfeasor rather than on the injured party. There was no justification for departing from this rule in the present case: all the tortfeasors had acted negligently and were at fault, and none could readily be identified as clearly playing only a secondary role. In the absence of clear grounds and substantive reasoning justifying an exception, the Court held that all the tortfeasors should be held jointly and severally liable.

The Court added that the allocation of liability among the tortfeasors themselves is determined by considerations of justice and equity and their respective degrees of moral blameworthiness.

Insurance coverage

The Supreme Court held that there was no basis for interfering with the District Court’s findings concerning the existence of the insurance policy, its inclusion of third party liability coverage, or its applicability to the circumstances of the case. However, because the District Court had not expressly addressed the policy’s limit of liability, the Supreme Court found that intervention on that issue was warranted.

The Supreme Court explained that insurance policies must be interpreted according to the parties’ intentions, as inferred from the policy wording and the circumstances. Where the contract’s subjective purpose cannot be established, its commercial purpose must be determined objectively, by reference to the intentions of “reasonable and fair” parties.

Since Clal Insurance had not submitted the full policy wording to the Court, the Supreme Court interpreted the coverage by examining the insured’s legal obligations. In this case, the insured was the construction company that had won a Ministry of Construction and Housing tender.

The Ministry’s requirements for carrying out construction work included an insurance policy with third party liability coverage subject to a limit of NIS 450,000 to NIS 500,000. The Supreme Court therefore interpreted the insurance contract between the parties accordingly.

The judgment stated that the same conclusion could also be reached by combining two additional interpretive principles drawn from American law that had not yet been adopted in binding precedent: the insured’s reasonable expectations doctrine, and an approach that considers the premium paid, whereby a premium above the customary level tends to support an interpretation providing broader coverage.

In light of these considerations, Clal Insurance’s limit of liability was set at NIS 480,000.

The judgment under appeal:


Regarding the division of liability, the District Court, whose ruling was appealed, determined that the incident reflects a situation in which several wrongdoers caused one damage, which physically cannot be divided. However, it was determined that the extent of the contribution of each of the various wrongdoers to the damage is indeed quantifiable conceptually, and therefore, each of the wrongdoers is liable for compensation in accordance with the extent of his contribution to the formation of the damage.


The District Court added that during the period relevant to the incident, the insured was insured with a contractor's work insurance policy, including coverage for third-party damages.
The District Court rejected Clal's argument that the damages incurred were excluded from the standard insurance policy, as the damage was caused by the removal or weakening of the ground support down the slope. It was determined that Clal's interpretation is unreasonable and inconsistent with the purpose and existence of the policy, since it effectively empties the policy of its content, since most contracting work begins with excavation in the ground.

The appeal hearing: The Supreme Court ruled that in this case, the damage caused by the violation of the duty of care by the wrongdoers is one, and each of them took part in the events that led to the landslide, in a way that cannot be divided and separately attributed to any of them.
The Supreme Court emphasized that liability for joint and several wrongdoers is imposed jointly and severally , and in particular where one of the wrongdoers is not solvent, then the damage "rolls over" to one of the wrongdoers and not to the injured party. In this case, there is no room for deviation from the rule since the conduct of all the wrongdoers was tainted with negligence and fault, and also because it is difficult to define which of them constitutes a clearly secondary wrongdoing. In the absence of clear reasons for this, and in the absence of a real reasoning justifying an exception to the rule, it was determined that all the wrongdoers should be held liable "jointly and severally."


He further added that the examination of the relative responsibility of the wrongdoers in the relationship between themselves is done according to justice and fairness and the degree of moral guilt of those involved.
In the issue concerning insurance coverage, it was determined that in the case at hand, there is no reason to interfere with the District Court's findings regarding the very existence of the insurance policy, which also includes liability towards a third party, as well as regarding the applicability of the policy to the circumstances of the case. However, since the District Court did not explicitly address the issue of the limit of liability covered by the insurance policy, the Supreme Court found that there is a reason to interfere.


In this context, the Supreme Court noted that insurance policies must be interpreted according to the parties' understanding, as implied by the policy and the circumstances of the case, and when it is not possible to trace the subjective purpose of the contract - the business purpose of the contract must be determined according to its objective purpose, which will be examined in accordance with the understanding of "reasonable and fair" parties. In the same matter, and since Clal Insurance did not present the full text of the insurance policy to the court, the Supreme Court interpreted the coverage in light of the examination of the legal obligations of the insured, and in this case, the construction company that won the tender of the Ministry of Construction and Housing.


In light of this, and since the Ministry of Construction's requirements for performing contract work include the existence of an insurance policy, which includes a third-party section with limited liability for an amount of 500,000-450,000 NIS, this was also the manner in which the Supreme Court found it appropriate to interpret the insurance contract between the parties. The same conclusion was determined in the ruling, and it is also possible to reach the same conclusion from the combination of two additional interpretative principles that have not yet been adopted in case law and which are drawn from American law: the rule of the insured's reasonable expectations, and the truth of the interpretation that examines the amount of the premium paid (the higher the premium than is customary, the tendency to attribute it to broader coverage). In light of all of this, the limit of liability of Clal Insurance was set at 480,000 NIS.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

The Supreme Court takes another step, this time in interpreting a contractors' insurance policy.

​

​

​

The Supreme Court takes another step, this time in interpreting a contractors' insurance policy.
Documents
Back
The Supreme Court takes another step, this time in interpreting a contractors' insurance policy.
bottom of page