top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

Construction work or eye work?

Nov 16, 2020

Construction work or eye work?

By: Shlomi Hadar, Adv. – John Geva, Geva, Hadar & Co., Attorneys at Law


The Lod District Court recently heard a claim in the amount of NIS 4,921,143 filed for damages allegedly caused to the plaintiffs as a result of construction works carried out in their home. The plaintiffs, who reside in a private house with seven levels, claimed that they hired the defendant to perform waterproofing works on the roof of their home due to leakage and dampness.


The plaintiffs alleged that the defendant was initially asked to carry out a localized repair—waterproofing the roof of the storage room located in the northern wing outside the structure, and the ceiling of the living room wing on the western side. However, during the work, the defendant identified various defects and persuaded the plaintiffs to carry out a comprehensive repair, including the removal of the tiled roof, claiming that the tiles were “unsuitable for the climate,” and the installation of a sealing system for the roof and the walls of the house.


The plaintiffs further claimed that after all the roof tiles were removed, rainwater penetrated into the house. They also alleged that the defendant relocated nine external air-conditioning units that had been installed in recesses within the walls of the upper roof, asserting that “rainwater seeps in this area,” and that in the place of the recess he poured a concrete block weighing 40 tons, without any engineering justification, thereby impairing the structural stability of the building.


According to the plaintiffs, this concrete casting led to the blockage of the air-conditioning piping and the shutdown of the air-conditioning system. It was further alleged that the negligent construction actions carried out by the defendant also caused water infiltration through the walls of the house, and that the defendant damaged the exterior walls of the house and the drywall at the base of the front and side windows of the home.


The plaintiffs additionally claimed that the defendant presented himself as an engineer specializing in roofs and construction, and as a member of the Israeli Association of Renovation Contractors, and claimed to have performed construction work for senior public figures in the country, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Knesset member Avigdor Lieberman—claims that later proved to be false. The plaintiffs also alleged that the defendant misrepresented to them that a foreign oligarch was interested in purchasing the house if the repairs were carried out, but it later transpired that the “oligarch” was in fact the uncle of the defendant’s wife, at which point the plaintiffs realized that they had fallen victim to fraud.

​

Construction work or eye work?

​

​

The defendant argued that the claimants had approached him and agreed that he would repair their roof. The agreed work included waterproofing two flat roof areas above the storeroom in the northern wing and part of the living room ceiling, repairing gutters near the kitchen, adding sheet metal to the storeroom frame, and sealing skylights above the kitchen. According to the defendant, the claimants subsequently requested additional renovations to the roof and exterior walls. He further alleged that they had refused to pay for completion of the work and still owed him NIS 700,000. He also raised numerous other arguments denying the allegations against him.

The Court accepted that the defendant held an engineering degree from abroad, was a member of the Renovation Contractors Association, and was a roofing tradesman. It also found that the claimants had indeed asked him to expand the scope of the renovations. Nevertheless, it accepted the court appointed expert’s opinion that the cladding work and removal of the tiled roof had been performed negligently and contained defects resulting from poor workmanship.

The Court described the defendant’s repairs as “patch upon patch,” stemming from fundamental failures in execution, and held that the claimants were entitled to a much higher standard of finish. It therefore concluded that the work did not meet the defendant’s contractual obligations and that the appropriate remedy was to restore the property to its previous condition. Accordingly, the defendant was required to refund the payments received.

Regarding the claimants’ allegations of dampness, the Court accepted its expert’s opinion that the defendant had not undertaken repairs to the foundation beams in contact with the ground and was therefore not responsible for water entering through them. It also found that he had not been engaged to repair openings on the entrance level. His responsibility was consequently limited to the dampness defects he had undertaken to remedy.

As for the concrete works, the Court found the defendant’s account implausible. He acknowledged receiving the payments but produced no work orders documenting them or establishing that they had been intended solely for purchasing concrete. Text messages and recorded conversations submitted in evidence also linked him to the concrete works, despite his assertion that these had been performed by workers engaged by the claimants.

The Court also considered whether the defendant had refunded the money after withdrawing from the concrete works. It found that this account was inconsistent, among other things, with a text message he sent to one of the claimants stating, “Tomorrow we’ll be at your place with the concrete.” The message was sent five days after the date on which he claimed to have refunded the money.

Regarding the concrete block cast on the roof, the court appointed expert concluded that there had been no engineering need for it and that it should be demolished and removed. The Court quoted the expert’s explanation that placing a 20 tonne concrete block above a ground level dwelling was “unconventional and unreasonable” and required a building permit. It therefore ordered the defendant to bear the removal costs.

Ultimately, the Court awarded the claimants NIS 323,300 plus VAT to restore the property to its previous condition, NIS 2,188,560 in refunded payments, NIS 50,000 for emotional distress, and NIS 25,000 in costs.

This case reflects many situations in which construction work proceeds without adequate professional support, clear written agreements, or appropriate insurance. Unfortunately, publicity surrounding such cases tarnishes an entire industry, most of which has recognized the importance of combining professionalism, integrity, and a financial safety net.

The defendant's claim

The defendant claimed that the plaintiffs approached him and agreed that he would repair the roof of the house for them, including sealing two flat roofs above the roof of the warehouse located in the north wing and part of the living room ceiling, repairing gutters near the kitchen, adding sheet metal to the warehouse frame and sealing ceiling windows above the kitchen, and later the plaintiffs decided to carry out additional renovations to the roof and the exterior walls of the house. The defendant added that the defendants refused to pay for the completion of the work and remained indebted to him for 700,000 NIS and added a long list of claims in which he denies what is attributed to him.


The court was impressed that the defendant did indeed have an engineering degree from abroad, was registered as a member of the Renovation Contractors Association, and was a roofing professional, and even determined that the plaintiffs did indeed ask the defendant to expand the scope of the renovations in their home. At the same time, the court accepted the position of the expert appointed by the court, who believed that the cladding work and removal of the tiled roof were carried out negligently, and contained defects resulting from poor workmanship. The court determined that the repairs carried out by the defendant were nothing more than "patchwork additions," resulting from substantial failures in the performance of the work, and the plaintiffs are entitled to a much higher level of finish. Therefore, the court decided that the work carried out by the defendant did not comply with his obligation, and the appropriate solution in the circumstances of the case is to restore the situation to its original state. Therefore, the court determined that the defendant must return the money they paid to the plaintiffs.


As for the plaintiffs' claim regarding moisture defects, the court accepted the opinion of the expert on their behalf, who believed that the defendant did not repair the foundation beams that come into contact with the ground, and therefore water infiltration from there is not his responsibility. The court also determined that the defendant was not hired to repair the openings on the entrance floor, and is therefore only responsible for the moisture defects that he was supposed to repair. As for the plaintiffs' claim regarding the concrete work, the court determined that the defendant's version is unfounded. The defendant admitted the money that was paid to him, did not present work orders documenting the receipt of amounts to prove that these were paid to him for the purpose of purchasing concrete only, and it can be learned from text correspondence and recorded conversations that were attached, that the defendant "tied" himself to the performance of the concrete work regarding which he claimed that these were performed by workers on behalf of the plaintiffs. The court was also required to decide the question of whether the defendant returned the money to the plaintiffs after he "withdrew" his hand from the concrete work, and ruled that this version is inconsistent, among other things, with a text message that he sent to the plaintiff in which he wrote, "Tomorrow we'll be at your place with the concrete," a message that was sent 5 days after he allegedly returned the money to the plaintiffs.


Regarding the casting of the concrete cube on the roof, the court's expert expressed his opinion that there was no engineering need to cast a concrete block on the roof of the plaintiffs' house, and therefore it should be dismantled and removed from the site. The court quoted the expert's words, who explained that placing a 20-ton concrete block on top of a ground-level housing unit was "unacceptable and unreasonable," even though a building permit was required to do so. Therefore, the court ruled that the defendant must bear the costs of removing the cube.

Ultimately, the court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in the amount of 323,300 NIS plus VAT for restoring the situation to its previous state, a total of 2,188,560 NIS for the reimbursement of the payments made, a total of 50,000 NIS for emotional distress, and the plaintiffs' expenses in the amount of 25,000 NIS.


This case is typical of many cases in which contractor work is carried out without appropriate professional guidance, without clear written agreements, without appropriate insurance. Unfortunately, cases like these that are published tarnish an entire industry, most of which internalizes the great importance of combining professionalism, fairness, and a safety net.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Construction work or eye work?

​

​

​

Construction work or eye work?
Documents
Back
Construction work or eye work?
bottom of page