top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

When the sky falls

Nov 18, 2021

When the sky falls

Ceiling Collapse in a Restaurant on a Diner


By: Adv. Shlomi Hadar – John Geva, Hadar & Co., Attorneys and Mediators


Background

Recently (September 20, 2021), a court ruling was issued concerning a claim for bodily injuries sustained by a diner in a restaurant, following the fall of part of the restaurant’s ceiling onto her. According to the claim, the accident occurred in 2013 after the plaintiff had seated herself at her table in the restaurant where the incident allegedly took place. As a result of the accident, the plaintiff sustained injuries to her back, neck, and shoulders.


The lawsuit was filed against the restaurant and its insurer, claiming that the accident resulted from their negligence. The restaurant filed a third-party notice against the contractor who installed the ceiling (hereinafter: “the contractor”), and in turn, the contractor filed a notice against the insurer – Menorah Insurance – which had insured him (hereinafter: “the insurer”).

​

When the sky falls

​

Parties’ Claims

The restaurant argued that the part of the ceiling that fell near the plaintiff was an element of a suspended acoustic ceiling and did not fall directly on the plaintiff. The restaurant also claimed that the incident was “sudden” and unforeseeable. Furthermore, it argued that if liability were to be established, it should be assigned to the contractor who installed the ceiling.


On the other hand, the contractor stated that although he had performed renovation work for the restaurant, after completion, the restaurant made substantial changes without his knowledge—for example, the installation of ceiling fans in a non-professional manner, attaching them to the suspended ceiling rather than to the concrete ceiling above, without using anchors appropriate for hanging such fans. The contractor further argued that if liability were imposed on him, the insurer should be required to indemnify him for any obligations arising.


The insurer rejected the contractor’s claims, adding that the contractor had been issued a contractors’ works insurance policy intended to cover the work performed by him. According to the general terms of the policy, the insurance ends immediately for any project—or part thereof—that is delivered to the project owner, put into use, or completed, whichever occurs first, even if these dates occur before the policy’s stated expiration date. Since the alleged accident occurred several months after the completion of the contractor’s work, the insurer argued that at the time of the incident, the contractor’s work was no longer covered by insurance.

​

Discussion and decision

After hearing the parties' arguments and examining the evidence in the case, the court determined that the lawsuit, and the third-party notice filed against the contractor, should be accepted.

The court ruled that there is no dispute that that part of the ceiling "fell" not as a result of an external event, such as an earthquake, and no opinion was submitted by the restaurant or the contractor to prove the cause of the fall.


This type of incident should not have occurred, especially in the presence of guests in the restaurant, exposing them to a significant safety risk. The "panic and terror" of witnessing a ceiling collapse "above one's head," and the moment there is a real danger of bodily harm, is enough to establish non-pecuniary damage.


The court noted that in the circumstances of the case, the evidentiary rule set out in Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance applied, which shifts the burden of proof to the shoulders of the restaurant owner and the contractor to prove that they were not negligent, but they did not discharge this burden. The court further determined that it emerged from the testimonies that there was a signed contract of engagement between the restaurant and the contractor, for the purpose of performing the work in the restaurant, however, neither of them attached the contract in order to trace the limits of the contractor's liability according to the terms of the contract. In addition, the restaurant and the contractor did not present work plans, an architectural plan, a construction plan, nor an engineering certificate from an engineer, work supervisor or professional confirming the soundness of the ceiling or the soundness of the accessories that were hung on it. In fact, from the evidence presented by the restaurant and the contractor, it was not possible to determine what caused the fall.

Discussion and Decision

After hearing the parties’ arguments and examining the evidence, the Court held that both the claim and the third party claim against the contractor should be upheld.

There was no dispute that the section of ceiling had fallen without an external event, such as an earthquake. Neither the restaurant nor the contractor submitted an expert opinion establishing the cause of the collapse.

Such an incident should not have occurred, particularly while guests were present and exposed to a significant safety risk. The “fear and terror” of witnessing a ceiling collapse overhead, coupled with a real threat of bodily injury, were sufficient to establish nonpecuniary damage.

The Court noted that the evidential rule in Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance applied, shifting the burden to the restaurant owner and the contractor to prove that they had not been negligent. Neither discharged that burden.

The testimony also established that the restaurant and the contractor had signed an agreement for the works. However, neither submitted it, preventing the Court from examining the contractual limits of the contractor’s responsibility.

Nor did they produce work plans, architectural plans, structural plans, or certification from an engineer, work inspector, or other professional confirming the safety of the ceiling or the fixtures suspended from it. Ultimately, the evidence presented by the restaurant and the contractor did not establish what had caused the collapse.

​

Accordingly, and given the fact that the ceiling collapse occurred inside the restaurant, and therefore the owner owed a duty of care to the restaurant's guests, and given the fact that the contractor was the one who installed the ceiling several months before the accident, and he also owed a duty of care to those staying under the product he built, since neither of them proved the cause of the collapse, the court ruled that the restaurant and the contractor are jointly and severally liable in equal shares for the accident.

As for the third-party notice, the court noted that the insurance is for the period defined in the policy, and is activated when the insured declares a specific project, and covers the damage that occurs in the course of performing the work on that project. That is, when the insured completes and delivers the work to the client, he informs the insurer, and the insurance for the specific project ends, but the policy continues to be valid in relation to additional active projects, if any.


The court ruled that since the incident occurred about six months after the end of the work period under the policy, and in any case after its expiration, there is no insurance coverage for the accident that occurred. Furthermore, it was not a restriction that negates or restricts insurance coverage, but rather the policy no longer applies to the incident, since the work on it had been completed. In addition, the contractor did not prove that the policy also applies to events after the insurance expired.


The court further added that the insurer's representative explained that in order to cover damages caused to third parties due to work after the said insurance has expired, insurance called "product liability" must be purchased. This insurance is a "policy in itself" and the deductible is high, as is the cost of the premium, and it was not proven that the contractor purchased this type of insurance.


End of the matter

The court accepted the lawsuit and the notice to the third party and ordered the restaurant and the contractor to compensate the plaintiff (the guest at the restaurant who was injured) in the amount of 38,000 NIS, plus legal costs and attorney fees.

​

Since the ceiling collapsed inside the restaurant, its owner owed a duty of care to the guests. The contractor, who had installed the ceiling several months before the accident, also owed a duty of care to those beneath the structure he had built. As neither party established the cause of the collapse, the Court held the restaurant and the contractor jointly and severally liable for the accident, allocating responsibility equally between them.

Regarding the fourth party claim, the Court explained that the insurance applied for the period specified in the policy and was activated when the insured declared a particular project. It covered damage occurring during the execution of that project’s works. Once the insured completed and handed over the work to the client, the insurer would be notified and coverage for that particular project would end. The policy would nevertheless remain in force for any other active projects.

The Court held that, because the accident occurred approximately six months after the insured works period had ended, and therefore after coverage had expired, the incident was not insured. This was not a policy exclusion restricting or removing coverage. Rather, the policy no longer applied to the project because the work had been completed. The contractor had also failed to establish that the policy covered incidents occurring after the insurance period.

The Court further noted the insurer’s representative’s explanation that covering damage caused to third parties by completed work after that coverage ends requires product liability insurance. This is a separate policy with a substantial deductible and premium. There was no evidence that the contractor had purchased such insurance.

Outcome

The Court upheld the claim and the third party claim, ordering the restaurant and the contractor to pay the claimant, the injured restaurant guest, NIS 38,000, plus legal costs and lawyers’ fees.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

When the sky falls

​

​

​

When the sky falls
Documents
Back
When the sky falls
bottom of page