top of page
Itzick Simon
English Logo

The liability of an employer who did not insure an employee in a pension fund for loss of disability benefits

May 26, 2025

The liability of an employer who did not insure an employee in a pension fund for loss of disability benefits

By: Itzick Simon, Sob 


 What are the steps to prove entitlement to compensation from an employer for the loss of disability benefits from the pension fund? 


 Background

 In judgment 1342-01-24, Meir Ben Shaton v. Rafael Turgeman, issued on October 10, 2024, the National Labor Court was required to discuss the question of whether an employee is entitled to compensation for the loss of a disability benefit from a pension fund due to his employer's failure to join the fund.

 The appellant, a warehouseman who resigned following surgery to remove a tumor from his pancreas, was not included in a pension insurance arrangement by his employer as required by law. After the surgery, the appellant was recognized by the National Insurance Institute as disabled with a degree of disability of 100% and he receives a general disability pension. Since 2019, the appellant has been recognized as having a stable medical disability of 73% and a stable degree of disability of 100%.

 The appellant filed a lawsuit against his employer for loss of disability pension, but the regional court dismissed the lawsuit, inter alia because the appellant did not prove his disability and his entitlement to insurance or a pension. It was also determined that in the absence of an actuarial opinion, the rate of damage was not quantified.


​

The liability of an employer who did not insure an employee in a pension fund for loss of disability benefits

The parties' claims

The appellant claimed that the National Insurance Institute's decision to pay some disability indicates his entitlement to compensation. In the appeal, he requested that the proceedings be returned to the regional court in order to supplement his evidence with an expert opinion that would prove his loss of work capacity and the damages. The respondent opposed the return of the proceedings, arguing that in any case the appellant would not have been accepted for insurance and would not have been entitled to a disability pension due to his medical condition prior to the start of his work.

The court's decision

The court's decision

xistence of a substantive right: The mandatory pension expansion order requires employers to insure employees in a pension arrangement after six months of employment. Breach of this obligation requires the employer to compensate an employee who was recognized as "disabled" according to the pension fund regulations or the survivors of a deceased employee for the value of the pension loss incurred by them.

 Pension or insurance: The court clarified that a distinction must be made between a claim for loss of rights in a pension fund and a claim for loss of rights in an insurance plan. Despite the existence of common points of contact, there are substantial differences between them: 

  1.  The definition of the event that qualifies for a disability pension - differs between pension fund regulations and insurance policies 
  2.  How the underwriting is conducted - An insurance plan is subject to the provisions of the Insurance Contract Law, 5741-1981, and underwriting therein is conducted in advance based on a health declaration, while in a pension fund, underwriting is generally not conducted in advance and in any case, underwriting is conducted retrospectively . 

Existence of a Substantive Right: The Extension Order on Mandatory Pension Coverage requires employers to provide employees with pension coverage after six months of employment. Breaching this obligation requires the employer to compensate an employee who would have qualified as “disabled” under the pension fund’s rules, or the surviving dependants of a deceased employee, for the value of the pension benefits they lost.

Pension or Insurance: The Labour Court clarified that a distinction must be drawn between claims for lost pension fund entitlements and claims for lost benefits under an insurance plan. Despite some similarities, there are substantial differences:

  1. Definition of the Event Giving Entitlement to a Disability Pension: The definition differs between pension fund rules and insurance policies.

  2. Underwriting Process: An insurance plan is governed by the Insurance Contract Law, 1981, and is underwritten in advance based on a health declaration. Pension funds, by contrast, generally do not conduct underwriting in advance and, in any event, conduct a retrospective assessment.

The Labour Court explained that the insured’s rights are determined by the pension fund rules applicable at the relevant time. In this case, whether enrolling the appellant in Helman-Aldubi required medical underwriting must be assessed under the rules in force when the obligation to enrol him was breached. By contrast, whether he qualified as “disabled,” and whether any circumstances disqualified him from receiving a disability pension, must be assessed under the rules in force when the qualifying event occurred.

Where the employer selected a specific fund, such as Helman-Aldubi in this case, the employee’s rights must be assessed under that fund’s rules. Where no selected fund can be identified, the preferred approach is to use the rules of the largest pension fund or the fund named in the applicable industry collective agreement. The Court emphasized that enrolment under a default arrangement does not require the employee’s cooperation or advance underwriting.

The Initial Burden: Proving Disability, Its Duration, and Its Degree

The employee bringing the claim bears the burden of proving the disability, its duration, and its degree. The claimant must submit an expert opinion addressing these matters or ask the Court to appoint an expert. The medical disability described in the opinion must meet the definition of disability in the relevant pension fund rules.

Shifting the Burden: Exceptions to Entitlement

Pension fund rules contain several exceptions to entitlement to a disability pension. These include disability resulting from a qualifying event during a qualifying period, and disability for which compensation is available from another source, whether under legislation or through a tort claim.

The Court held that, while the insured bears the initial burden of proving disability, the fund bears the burden of establishing that an otherwise eligible insured person is not entitled to a pension because the qualifying period was not satisfied.

Filing the Claim

An employee seeking compensation from an employer for the loss of a disability pension must identify the legal basis for entitlement and the pension fund rules that would have applied had the employer fulfilled its obligations. The claim must also include an expert opinion establishing disability within the meaning of those rules, or a reasoned application for exemption from submitting such an opinion, together with a medical confidentiality waiver.

The Remedy

The Court noted that awarding relief in these claims presents particular challenges. Employees or their surviving dependants must claim pension losses before those losses have fully crystallized, while repeatedly suing the employer at intervals presents substantial practical difficulties.

Calculating the loss requires distinguishing between established facts, such as the salary the employer should have insured and the applicable insurance and investment tracks, and informed estimates of other factors. These include the duration and degree of disability over time and the insured’s life expectancy.

A claimant seeking compensation for future pension losses must submit a medical opinion addressing both their current condition and future prognosis, as well as an actuarial opinion assessing the loss of disability and retirement pension benefits. The Court emphasized that, although calculating future losses is inherently speculative to a considerable degree, addressing this uncertainty is an integral part of bodily injury claims.

The regulations

The court explained that the rights of the insured are determined according to the regulations in effect at the relevant time. In our case, the question of whether the appellant's joining Hellman-Aldoubi required the conduct of a medical underwriting procedure will be examined according to the regulations in effect at the time the obligation to join the fund was violated. In contrast, the definition of the appellant as "disabled" and the examination of the events that may deny his entitlement to receive a disability pension will be examined according to the regulations at the time of the occurrence of the qualifying event. In the event that the employer selected a specific fund (such as Hellman-Aldoubi in the case at hand), the employee's rights will be examined according to the regulations of that fund. In circumstances where it is not possible to indicate a selected pension fund, the best course of action would be to use the regulations of the largest fund or the regulations of the pension fund whose name is specified in the industry collective agreement. The court emphasized that joining the fund within the framework of a default covenant does not require cooperation from the employee and does not require prior underwriting. 


 The basic burden – proving the disability, its duration and extent: The burden of proving the disability, its duration and extent lies with the employee claimant . The claimant must present an expert opinion detailing the disability, its duration or extent or alternatively petition the court to appoint an expert on behalf of the court. The medical disability presented in the opinion must meet the definition of disability in the relevant regulations of the pension fund. 


 Transfer of the burden – exceptions to eligibility: The fund regulations contain a number of exceptions to a disabled person’s eligibility to receive a disability pension, including disability resulting from a qualifying event that occurred during the qualifying period and disability that entitles them to compensation from another source (legal provisions; tort claim). The court ruled that, in addition to the basic burden on an insured to prove his disability, the burden of proving that an insured who met the conditions for receiving a disability pension is not entitled to a pension due to his failure to meet the qualifying period lies with the fund and not with the insured. 


 Filing the claim: An employee claiming compensation from an employer for loss of disability pension must state in his claim the normative source of his entitlement, the relevant regulations that would have applied to him had it not been for the employer's negligence, an opinion indicating that he is "disabled" within the meaning of the term in the regulations or a reasoned request for exemption from filing the opinion, as well as a waiver of medical confidentiality. 


 Remedy : The court noted that ruling on relief in claims of this type poses unique challenges. The difficulty in these claims is the need for the employee or his/her survivors to claim the amounts of the pension losses even before they have been formed, in circumstances where there is a real difficulty in filing a claim against the employer once in a while. In calculating pension losses, a distinction must be made between certain data, such as the salary that the employer was required to insure, the insurance track and the investment track according to which the employee's losses will be calculated, and an informed assessment of additional estimated data, including the period of disability and the degree of disability over time and the life expectancy of the insured. The claimant for compensation for the loss of future pensions must submit a medical opinion that relates not only to a given situation but also to his/her future situation and an actuarial opinion regarding the loss of disability and old age pensions. The court emphasized that although the calculation of the future loss is largely speculative, dealing with it is an integral part of claims for personal injury.


​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

The liability of an employer who did not insure an employee in a pension fund for loss of disability benefits

Summary and implications

​

The National Court decided to return the proceedings to the Regional Court to allow the appellant to prove his claim through an opinion. This was "after proportionately weighing the procedural default on the one hand and the interest in discovering the truth on the other, and in order to allow the appellant to exercise his right of access to the courts."


 The ruling clarifies the procedural aspects of a compensation claim against an employer who failed to insure an employee in a pension fund. The court clarified that an employer may be exposed to a compensation claim for loss of disability benefits and that while the employee must prove his basic entitlement and the amount of compensation due to him, the employer has the burden of proving exceptions and limitations to entitlement.

​

The liability of an employer who did not insure an employee in a pension fund for loss of disability benefits
Documents
Back
The liability of an employer who did not insure an employee in a pension fund for loss of disability benefits
bottom of page